Best NHL Defenseman 2021

Now that a handful of games from the 2021 NHL regular season are in the books, we have enough information to start drawing some serious conclusions. This holds especially true for player rankings, and it's why we're taking this opportunity to discuss the best NHL defensemen in 2021.

Of course, because this season is still so young, we're not only basing our findings off the sub-10-game sample we're working with as of this writing. The beginning of any year is mostly about monitoring the pecking order for any seismic changes from the previous campaign.

To build our list of the NHL's best current defensemen, we'll rely heavily on what we saw from the top NHL defensemen in 2020, including the Stanley Cup playoffs. We will also take into account what we've watched thus far, in addition to how likely players are to hold their current position for the rest of the year.

And in case you're wondering, this snapshot of the NHL's defensive hierarchy does serve a sports-betting purpose. The folks over at Bovada actually provide odds for who will win Defensive Player of the Year. If nothing else, it clues you in on which teams to monitor as you consider any NHL futures.

Play Online Now

Bovada

Review

BONUS $250

BTC Bonus 75% up to $750!

The NHL Norris Trophy odds were last updated on April 30, 2021: 

Team
Colorado Avalanche	+400	+380	+450	+375
Tampa Bay Lightning	+700	+700	+700	+650
Vegas Golden Knights	+700	+600	+500	+700
Toronto Maple Leafs	+750	+750	+750	+750
Carolina Hurricanes	+750	+700	+700	+700
Pittsburgh Penguins	+1600	+1100	+1100	+1400
Boston Bruins	+1200	+1200	+1500	+1200
Washington Capitals	+1400	+1100	+1100	+1200
New York Islanders	+1700	+1600	+1600	+1400
Florida Panthers	+1900	+1600	+1600	+1600

Ranking Best NHL Defensemen

As always, our rankings will go in reverse order. We'll start with No. 10 and work our way up to No. 1. And remember: Defensemen are being ranked as if we're acquiring them for the entire 2021 NHL season.

10. Miro Heiskanen, Dallas Stars

Defense in the NHL is all about stamina. Miro Heiskanen has that covered for the Stars.

Not only did he lead the team in total ice time per game last year, but he went on to set a record in the postseason for points by a Dallas defenseman, tallying six goals and 20 assists. At only 21, many think he has a Norris Trophy in his future, suggesting he will only climb this list.

9. Charlie McAvoy, Boston Bruins

Known for getting off to slow starts, Charlie McAvoy is the quintessential finisher. Last year, in addition to leading the Bruins in ice time per game, he also paced the team in blocked shots while finishing third in total hits. 

All this, and he still managed to set his career-high in points, anchored by a personal-best 27 assists.

8. Kris Letang, Pittsburgh Penguins

Some veterans fade. Kris Letang isn't one of them.

The three-time Stanley Cup Champion finished third in the entire NHL in ice time per game last season. That is absurd. He continues to rank among the best in the business at killing power plays, and his 44 points are nothing at which to scoff.

7. Dougie Hamilton, Carolina Hurricanes

Sticking Dougie Hamilton inside the top seven is a little bit of a risk. He's working his way back from a broken fibula that limited his availability last season. 

And yet, the time he was available proved to be incredibly impactful. He racked up 40 points by mid-January, and no defenseman has scored more goals over the past three years.

6. Seth Jones, Columbus Blue Jackets

The 6'4" Seth Jones continues to be a revelation on the ice. Columbus leans on him not just for a ton of playing time in general, but to navigate their shorthanded stints. His size and length render him the equivalent of two defenders in certain spaces.

It also doesn't hurt that he's a playmaking wizard. He dropped 24 assists during the abridged 2019-20 campaign, and the year before, he finished with a whopping 41 assists. 

5. Alex Pietrangelo, Vegas Golden Knights

Though Alex Pietrangelo has spent the past half-decade suiting up for the St. Louis Blues, his skill set is already translating nicely to the Knights.

Capitalizing on power players continues to be his specialty. Also: Very few defensemen put as much pressure on the opposition's net. He scored 16 goals and launched 225 shots through 70 appearances last season.

4. Cale Makar, Colorado Avalanche

Cale Makar took home the Calder Trophy last season—the NHL's Rookie of the Year award—and he's delivering an adequate encore this year.

While Makar does need to improve his passing instincts and puck handling, he has proven to be a viable scoring threat and heavy hitter. His postseason performance in particular last season—four goals, 11 assists—suggests we should expect great things from the 22-year-old.

3. Roman Josi, Nashville Predators

Roman Josi is the reigning Norris Trophy winner, which means he has a case to be even higher. Among all defensemen, he ranked fifth in power-play points (23 goals, 19 assists) and third in net goal rating (plus-22).

If there's one thing holding him back, it's his shot-blocking. Josi isn't the tallest, and he lacks the east-west speed to effectively closeout. Still, this is all nitpicky. He's darn good.

2. Victor Hedman, Tampa Bay Lightning

Plenty of people would have Victor Hedman in the No. 1 spot. We're not here to argue with them. It's a close call.

Hedman is the entire package. He is 6'6", incredibly mobile, superphysical, boasts an excellent shot form, and perfectly marries speed and high IQ. It's all this that has made him a finalist for the Norris Trophy in each of the previous three seasons, and he shows little signs of slowing down.

1. John Carlson, Washington Capitals

John Carlson just edges out Hedman on the back of what he did last season. He led all defensemen in assists (60) and total points (75) while making real strides as a scorer.

His case is boosted further by his start to the 2021 campaign. He is flashing more accuracy when hanging around the net and is on pace to post a career-high shooting percentage—no small feat given that he's on the wrong side of 30.

Betting on the NHL

Check out the below list of the best online sportsbooks so you can decide which one to use for all your NHL betting:

Play Online Now

BetNow

Review

BONUS $1000

Bonus also available in BTC

Play Online Now

Intertops

Review

BONUS $500

Bonus also available in BTC

1

Bovada

Read Review

50% bonus up to $250

BONUS

$250

Play Now

2

BetOnline

Read Review

50% bonus up to $1000

BONUS

$1000

Play Now

3

BetUS

Read Review

125% up to $2,500

BONUS

$2500

Play Now

NHL Defenseman FAQs

1. Are NHL Norris Trophy odds worth playing?

The NHL Defenseman odds offer something different from the weekly moneyline, parlay, and props. They offer a futures market, or a betting line that can be accessed anytime throughout the week. Check them out, as another way to access NHL betting.

2. Who won the Norris Trophy in 2020?

Roman Josi of the Nashville Predators won the trophy. It was the first time he had been a finalist.

3. Why is it called the Norris Trophy?

The trophy is named after James E. Norris, who was the owner of the National Hockey League's Detroit Red Wings from 1932 to 1952. An honorary member of the NHL and someone people have looked up to over the years.

4. Which is the best online bookmaker for Norris trophy odds?

The best bookmaker is the one that suits the bettor the most. There are a variety of great bookmakers available, each offering its own unique betting selling point. We'd always strongly advise choosing the sportsbook that appeals most to you. Check out our list of oddsmakers for the very best around.

5. Can only defensive players win the Norris Trophy?

The Norris Trophy is designed specifically for defensive players. There are other trophies that are given to goaltenders, rookie players, and for the MVP each season - be sure to check those out too!