2021 NFL Prop Bets: Picks for Coach of the Year & Comeback Player of the Year

Eric Uribe
By , Updated on: Apr 9, 2024 08:00 PM
2021 NFL Prop Bets: Picks for Coach of the Year & Comeback Player of the Year

The time has come for a deep dive into all the important 2021 NFL prop bets. In fact, OSB has already started tackling the hottest awards. We dropped NFL player props for Offensive and Defensive Rookie of the Year and then covered whether Tom Brady is the favorite to win the 2021 MVP award.

Next up on our docket: 2021 NFL prop bets for Coach of the Year, Comeback Player of the Year and Defensive Player of the Year.

To start us off, here's a look at the latest NFL prop betting odds for Comeback Player of the Year, courtesy of BetOnline:

Comeback Player of the Year PickBetOnline
Dak Prescott-1000
Joe Burrow+700
Nick Bosa+900
Carson Wentz+2000
James Connor+2000
Joe Mixon+3300

Since these NFL prop odds are accurate as of December 15, you'll want to double-check the lines before settling on your official NFL prop picks. These NFL betting odds will continue shifting right up until the end of the regular season.

For anyone who's looking to find a great NFL prop betting site, be sure to check out our reviews of the best online sportsbooks.

2021 NFL Prop Picks

Pretty much anyone who's anyone has penciled in Dak Prescott of the Dallas Cowboys to win Comeback Player of the Year. Is that accurate? 

For Defensive Player of the Year, meanwhile, most have their sights set on Myles Garrett of the Cleveland Browns. Is that the right call? And for Coach of the Year, Bill Belichick of the New England Patriots is believed to have a strong hold on the outcome. Should you follow the inclinations of the majority?

All these questions will be answered with our 2021 NFL prop betting picks...right now!

2021 NFL Comeback Player of the Year Prediction

Sometimes, the odds say it all. And this is one of those times.

Dak Prescott (-1000) embodies everything voters look for in Comeback Player of the Year: a star returning from a devastating injury. No one else on this list really comes close. Nick Bosa (+900) flirts with that status, as someone who should finish in the top five of Defensive Player of the Year voting.

Still, voters naturally gravitate toward offensive players. And Prescott just so happens to be the signal-caller for the second-rated offense in the league, a standing the Dallas Cowboys have achieved on the back of his career-best efficiency out of the pocket.

There's no decision to make here.

OSB Prediction: Dak Prescott (-1000)


Dak Prescott To win 2021 NFL Comeback Player of the Year

2021 NFL Coach of the Year Prediction

Have a look at the latest 2021 NFL Coach of the Year betting odds from BetOnline:

Coach of the Year PickBetOnline
Bill Belichick-110
Kliff Kingsbury+400
Matt LaFleur+800
Mike Vrabel+1600
Brandon Staley+1600
Sean McVay+2000
Zac Taylor+2000
Mike McCarthy+2500
Frank Reich+3300
Brian Flores+3300
Andy Reid+4000
Bruce Arians+4000
Ron Rivera+4000
Kyle Shanahan+5000
Nick Sirianni+8000

A majority of NFL prognosticators have Bill Belichick (-110) running away with this award. Their reasoning is pretty airtight. Belichick has guided a team that was supposed to be rebuilding up to the top of the AFC East while going on an historically impressive winning streak with a rookie quarterback in Mac Jones and a defense that ranks first in points allowed per game. 

Good luck finding a candidate to beat him. Kliff Kingsbury (+400) has a compelling case. The Arizona Cardinals have the league's best record and, perhaps, the best offense. But they were built to contend for a Super Bowl this season. New England wasn't—or so we thought. That surprise factor should carry Belichick to a Coach of the Year victory over competitors like Kingsbury, Matt LaFleur (+800) and Mike Vrabel (+1600).

OSB Prediction: Bill Belichick (-110)

Bill Belichick To win 2021 NFL Coach of the Year

2021 NFL Defensive Player of the Year Prediction

Below are the latest NFL Defensive Player of the Year betting odds from BetOnline:

Defensive Player of the Year PickBetOnline
Myles Garrett+250
Micah Parsons+300
TJ Watt+350
Aaron Donald+600
Matt Judon+1000
Nick Bosa+1200
Trevon Diggs+1400
Trey Hendrickson+3300
JC Jackson+3300
Devin White+4000
Shaquil Barrett+5000
Kevin Byard+5000

Myles Garrett (+250) has been an absolute monster for the Cleveland Browns this season. He's racked up 28 quarterback and 15 actual sacks—mind-boggling numbers for a 272-pound defensive end who draws the bulk of the offensive line's attention every snap. He has earned his slight favorite status.

However, Micah Parsons (+300) isn't far behind. The favorite to win NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year also has a case to be the best defensive player in football, period. Voters would typically be hesitant to give him dual honors, but Parsons is making it impossible not to consider him. He leads the entire league in tackles that go for a loss, and his quarterback pressure rivals that from Garrett. Parsons has 27 QB hits and 12 sacks on the year.

Given that Dallas has turned their season around on defense lately, we're inclined to roll with the rookie over Garrett. No one player can define an entire defense, but playing for the better team always goes a long way with the voters.

OSB Prediction: Micah Parsons (+300)

Micah Parsons To win 2021 NFL Defensive Player of the Year

Take a look at this list of the top online sportsbooks so you can decide which one to use for all your NFL betting:

Meet the author

Eric Uribe

Eric has been passionate about sports since he was 10 years old. He brings over 10 years of sports journalism experience to his expert coverage of sports betting. Hailing from the US, Eric leverages his diverse expertise covering sports at all levels – from high sch...

Online Sports Betting may receive compensation if you sign up through our links. Rest assured, we avoid biases and provide honest opinions on sportsbooks. Read more here.