Underdog Blue Jays bite back against favored Yankees

Tony Reyes
By , Updated on: May 16, 2023 08:00 PM
Underdog Blue Jays bite back against favored Yankees
  • When: Wednesday, May 17 at 7:07 PM ET
  • Who: Yankees at Blue Jays
  • Starting Pitchers: Gerrit Cole and Chris Bassitt
  • Where: Rogers Centre in Toronto, ON

The New York Yankees and Toronto Blue Jays are two of the best teams in the American League, and they will meet for the final game of a three-game series at Rogers Centre today.

Before continuing, we must advise you to check out our MLB Betting Guide, which will help you prepare for any MLB props you may be interested in.

Game Preview

The Blue Jays are trying to avoid being swept after losing their first home series of the season.

They need to remember to play with confidence and determination in front of their home crowd because a win against the Yankees would only solidify their status as a legitimate threat in the American League East.

The Yankees are led by Aaron Judge, Gerrit Cole, and Giancarlo Stanton. Judge is the reigning AL MVP, and he has 11 home runs and 26 RBIs.

Toronto's lineup includes the likes of Vladimir Guerrero Jr., Bo Bichette, and Teoscar Hernandez – all capable of doing some serious damage at the plate.

However, with Cole on the mound for the Yankees, the Blue Jays could struggle to get their bats swinging and drive in some runs.

Money LineBetOnlineBovadaBetUS
Blue Jays+104+100+104

So, as we gear up for tonight's showdown between the Yankees and the Blue Jays, it's time to determine which team we will put our faith in.

Are the favored Yankees the play at -114 on the money line? Or should we back the underdog Blue Jays at +104?

We want to ensure you make the most of the best sign-up bonuses and current promotions. Taking advantage of these bonuses can significantly increase your bankroll allowing you to bet with house money!

I would not recommend betting on the favored Yankees, it's very difficult to sweep a team and they don't have the best price at -114.

New York Yankees To win game

Total Runs

The Yankees are the favorites to win this game, but the Blue Jays are a dangerous team.

Total RunsBetOnlineBovadaBetUS
Over 8.5 Runs+105-100-110
Under 8.5 Runs-110-120-105

Now, let's talk about that over 8.5 runs at +105. The Yankees offense exploded last night, but the Blue Jays have their firepower that shouldn't be underestimated.

These are two high-powered offenses that both ranks in the top-15 in baseball in runs scored. The Blue Jays haven't played in a game with less than 11 runs in 3 straight games.

Furthermore, the Yankees haven't played in a game with less than 9 runs in 10 games! These teams scoring over 8.5 runs feels like a sure thing in this one.

Both team's lineups can put up runs in bunches and with the way these teams have been swinging the bats lately, we wouldn't be shocked to see a high-scoring affair.

The over/under is set at 8.5 runs, and I think this game will be high-scoring. I would take the over in this game.

Over 8.5 Runs Toronto Blue Jays vs New York Yankees

Money Line

I'm backing the Blue Jays to prevent getting swept and win this one. Even though they are facing the Yankees Ace pitcher in Gerrit Cole, I think everyone is underestimating Chris Bassitt for the Blue Jays.

He's had a strong season so far, recording 5 wins and 2 losses, while racking up 41 strikeouts with an ERA of 3.49.

Cole has been magnificent for the Yankees this season, taking an unbeaten 5-0 record along with 62 strikeouts and an ERA of 2.22 into this matchup.

I'm sticking with the Blue Jays to pull off the upset and with this one, +104 odds indicate a little less than 49% so this game is pretty close to a coin flip.

I'll take the plus-money odds and the desperate team in this matchup.

I would recommend betting on the Blue Jays to win on the money line.

Toronto Blue Jays To win game

Make sure to check our top sportsbook reviews for the best odds on your favorite MLB prop bets before placing your bets.

Meet the author

Tony Reyes

With years of experience as an analyst, Tony brings an expert voice to picks and predictions. His love of sports betting comes through in coverage that informs and entertains in equal measure. You can find Tony shooting hoops or cycling the local trails when not watchin...

Online Sports Betting may receive compensation if you sign up through our links. Rest assured, we avoid biases and provide honest opinions on sportsbooks. Read more here.